Use Case – ST-210S-H1 Inkjet Thermal Printer vs GT-100E Handheld Thermal Inkjet Printer

  • Unattended inline high-speed printing
  • Up to 600 DPI code clarity
  • Cuts rework and scrap by half
  • Frees operator from manual coding
  • Fast payback on price difference

The Challenge

A medium-volume producer of food and cosmetics in northern Italy was applying batch numbers and expiry dates using the GT-100E Handheld Thermal Inkjet Printer. As the conveyor speed increased and the range of products expanded, operators found it increasingly difficult to keep pace, having to walk alongside the conveyor with the handheld device and halt production to correct misprints. Management faced a decision point: when to transition from handheld to a fixed inline printer, weighing the pros and cons of manual handheld coding versus a dedicated inline solution.

The main considerations included print resolution at full conveyor speed, operator efficiency, the rate of rework due to printing errors, and the total cost per coded pack.


Product B: GT-100E Handheld Thermal Inkjet Printer

The GT-100E Handheld Thermal Inkjet Printer provides versatile TIJ 2.5 marking, offering up to 300 DPI vertical resolution and print heights between 1 and 12.7 mm. While it is technically capable of matching conveyor speeds up to 406 m/min, in practical use the customer operated it by hand at approximately 60 m/min to ensure codes remained clear and properly aligned.

At 60% of its practical handheld throughput, a single operator marked around 14,600 packs/day during an 8-hour shift, factoring in walking time and occasional interruptions to correct misprints. Labour requirements amounted to one full-time operator at €25/hour, plus 20% of another operator’s time for product changeovers and rework, resulting in a direct coding labour cost of roughly €200/day.

Printing errors and smudged codes resulted in an estimated 2% rework or scrap rate, causing additional downtime and packaging waste. Although the GT-100E is an economical purchase at around €699, the handheld process became a limiting factor as production volumes increased.


Product A: ST-210S-H1 Inkjet Thermal Printer

The ST-210S-H1 Inkjet Thermal Printer is a fixed-position TIJ 2.5 unit designed for continuous inline operation. It achieves up to 600 x 600 DPI resolution with a 12.7 mm print height and maintains reliable printing at speeds up to 406 m/min at 90 DPI, or 60 m/min at 600 DPI, matching the conveyor’s full speed while maintaining top print quality.

Installed directly above the conveyor and activated by sensors, the ST-210S-H1 operated at 60% of its inline capacity, coding approximately 19,500 packs/day over the same 8-hour shift, without requiring an operator to follow the line. One operator could now oversee three lines using the 7-inch industrial touch screen and integrated Linux interface, reducing labour dedicated to coding to about €75/day.

Consistent 600 DPI printing on cartons and plastic films reduced misprints and unreadable codes by more than 50%, lowering the rework or scrap rate from 2% to around 0.8%. The printer’s compatibility with water-based, solvent, UV, invisible, and food-grade inks also made it easier to comply with requirements across various product types.


ROI & Value Assessment

Product B Results:

Product A Results:

Assuming a cautious packed product value of €0.20 per pack, the reduction in scrap equates to a saving of roughly 135 packs per day × €0.20 ≈ €27 per day. Labour cost reduction amounts to €125 per day (€200 minus €75).
Combined, the daily savings with Product A are approximately €152 per day.

Investment Evaluation:
Product B cost: €699
Product A cost: €1,299
Difference in cost: €600
Daily savings with Product A: €152 per day
Recouping the price difference: less than one month (about 4 working days)

After recouping the investment, Product A can process around 4,900 additional packs per day, offering further capacity for increased volumes without the need for extra staff.


Conclusion

Opt for Product B if your expenditure limit is strictly below €1,000, your daily volume remains under 10,000 packs, and you require maximum portability for infrequent or off-line coding tasks.

Opt for Product A if your operation uses a continuous conveyor, you require 600 DPI coding at full line speed, wish to minimise rework and scrap, and intend to relieve operators from following the line. For the majority of medium-volume producers, the ST-210S-H1 Inkjet Thermal Printer represents the best long-term value, with a payback period on the price difference of well under a month and clear improvements in consistency, throughput, and labour productivity.

“After upgrading from the handheld GT-100E to the inline ST-210S-H1, we achieved stable 600 DPI codes at full speed and halved our rework. Our team no longer needs to follow the line with a handheld device, and the extra €600 was recovered in under two weeks.” — Luca Bianchi, Production Manager, Alpi Foods, Parma (Italy)